Home In the News By Seeking to Block Publication of Two Books, Trump World Will Face...

By Seeking to Block Publication of Two Books, Trump World Will Face the “Streisand Effect”

A couple of quick tips if you’re in the book publishing world:

First tip: If you’re a giant New York-based book publisher, try to get under the skin of the most powerful person in the world.

Second tip: If you’re the most powerful person in the world and want to suppress information, do not sue potential authors and publishers who want to write about you.

Case in point: the president.

President Trump and his surrogates have tried twice in the last month to prevent publications of books that are – or will be – critical of him personally and politically. He or his surrogates have specifically targeted tell-all books by the former White House National Security Advisor, John Bolton, and more recently the president’s niece, Mary Trump, who promises to unleash dirt on the president and other members of the family.

Rather than succeed in thwarting unwarranted publicity, these two books – both of which are being published by Simon and Schuster – are now No. 1 and No. 2 on the Amazon bestseller list. On June 26, Bolton’s book, “The Room Where It Happened,” was No. 1, and Mary Trump’s book, “Too Much and Never Enough:  How May Family Created the World’s Most Dangerous Man,” was No. 2.

By June 28, they had swapped the top two positions.

Efforts to curtail speech such as these are destined to produce was is known as the “Streisand Effect.”  

As a Wikipedia entry has aptly described it, the “Streisand effect” is a “social phenomenon that occurs when an attempt to hide, remove, or censor information has the unintended consequence of further publicizing that information, often via the Internet.”

The moniker stems from the iconic singer and actress Barbra Streisand’s efforts to suppress the dissemination of aerial photographs of her residence in Malibu, California in 2003.  

Prior to Streisand’s lawsuit for invasion of privacy, the photograph in question had been downloaded just six times from the photographer’s website.  After Streisand sued, more than 420,000 people visited the photographer’s site.

Streisand lost the lawsuit and was ordered to pay the photographer’s legal fees, amounting to more than $150,000.  

Other attempts to censor speech have met similar fates.

Perhaps the books by Bolton and Mary Trump would not have generated huge interest much beyond Washington Beltway wonks, but the president and some family members undoubtedly propelled the books into national successes.

Simon and Schuster will be laughing all the way to the bank.

Robert D. Lystad is the Executive Director of the non-profit Campaign for Free Speech, based in Washington, D.C.

Must Read

The Many Lawsuits of Devin Nunes

Perhaps the headline writer for a Washington Post opinion column framed it best:  “Raise your hand if you have not been sued by Devin...

Don’t Cancel the First Amendment

Originally published by National Review, written by Charles C. W. Cooke. Of all the strange and fanciful notions that have bubbled up to the surface...

Court Clears Mary Trump’s Tell-All Book for Publication, But Efforts Continue to Block Other Books

A New York appellate court lifted a restraining order on the publisher of Mary Trump’s explosive tell-all book, which apparently will describe a “nightmare...

New York Judge Temporarily Blocks Tell-All Book Authored by President Trump’s Niece

In at least a temporary blow to the First Amendment rights of free speech and a free press, a state court judge in Poughkeepsie,...

Trump Family Seeks to Silence One of Their Own: President’s Brother Sues to Prevent Publication of Tell-All Book by President’s Niece

Fresh off an unsuccessful bid to have a federal court block the publication of former National Security Advisor John Bolton’s tell-all book about the...