Home Legal Prager University v. Google

Prager University v. Google

Amid all the rancor by presidential candidates, other politicians, and some of the public at large to regulate speech among social media outlets large and small, comes this bit of harsh reality to some.  Most social media is not a public forum.  Social media by and large consists of private entities.  Facebook, Instagram, YouTube.  They can publish and broadcast what they want.  And they can generally ban speech they don’t want.

It is well established under the First Amendment that the government should not be telling private entities – or private individuals, for that matter – what they can and cannot say.  The latest court decision to confirm this proposition is Prager University v. Google.

PragerU, as it is known, alleged that YouTube and its parent company, Google, restricted access or the placing of ads on its website because of its conservative views (a similar argument by a “liberal” or “moderate” entity would make no difference).  PragerU argued that the ubiquity of YouTube had transformed itself into a public platform – like a public park where all are allowed to speak their minds pursuant to the First Amendment right to free speech.

Not so, said the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit. “Despite YouTube’s ubiquity and its role as a public-facing platform, it remains a private forum, not a public forum subject to judicial scrutiny under the First Amendment.”

Private businesses, just like private individuals, should be able to allow or restrict speech in their home environments as they see fit.  To do otherwise would lead to government control of freedom of speech.  That would not be a pretty sight.

Must Read

The Global Implications of the Coronavirus Pandemic on a Free Press

Among the many victims of the coronavirus pandemic is a free press.  Make no mistake, the press is not in nearly as precarious a...

The Coronavirus:  Different Approaches to Informing the Public from Around the World, and the Ensuing Dangers

Update 2-29-20:   After the White House apparently muzzled Dr. Anthony Fauci and other leading government medical officials to avoid inconsistent messages about potential catastrophic...

Prager University v. Google

Amid all the rancor by presidential candidates, other politicians, and some of the public at large to regulate speech among social media outlets large...

Live from Moscow, It’s Radio Putin!

Written by Neil MacFarquhar and published in The New York Times: Playing on Kansas City Radio: Russian Propaganda Radio Sputnik, a propaganda arm of the Russian...

When Will John Bolton be Permitted to Speak

Former National Security Adviser John Bolton has a story to tell.  His own story . . . about the delay in the delivery of...